On The Tonight Show this Thursday (April 27), Watson and Fallon rehashed their first awkward encounter — back when Fallon hosted Late Night — and Watson couldn’t keep herself together. Blushing, the Harry Potter alum confessed she mistook Fallon for fellow talk-show host Jimmy Kimmel.
“I love that Halloween candy thing that you do,” she told Fallon at the time, before their interview even began. Watson was referring to Kimmel’s annual gag of sharing videos parents made of themselves telling kids the Halloween candy was gone. “I died inside. I died inside,” she said, totally mortified. Looks like it’s back to the library for you, Hermione.